Best Fish for Aquaponics Systems

by Roger Loper

Which fish is best for aquaponics?

Aquaponics integrates aquaculture (raising fish) and hydroponics (growing plants in water) in a symbiotic system. Selecting the right fish is crucial, as they provide nitrates for the plants and contribute to system balance. The "best" fish depends on your goals (e.g., food production, ornamentation), climate, system size, and experience. Here’s a synthesis of key findings from the search results:

Key Factors Influencing Fish Choice:

  1. Climate and Temperature Tolerance: Fish are adapted to warm or cold water. Your local climate is a primary determinant. Also take into consideration what plants you can grow in the water temperature range needed for the fish.
  2. System Size and Scale: Large fish or high stocking densities require more space and robust filtration.
  3. Growth Rate and Harvest Goals: Fast-growing fish (e.g., tilapia) provide quicker returns for food production.
  4. Hardiness and Disease Resistance: Hardy fish tolerate water quality fluctuations and are better for beginners.
  5. Diet and Nutrient Output: Fish waste fertilizes plants mostly with ammonia that is converted to nitrate. You may get trace amounts of other nutrient/minerals from the fish waste, but typically that is not enough for the plants to grow and produce as desidred.
  6. Reproductive Habits: Prolific breeders (e.g., tilapia, guppies, blue gill) may require population control.
  7. Legal and Local Considerations: Some regions restrict non-native species; local fish are often easier to source. Before you get fish, check with the local fish and wildlife department to ensure your fish species is allowed or if you need to apply for a permit for the fish you would like to raise.

Top Fish Species for Aquaponics:

  1. Tilapia:
    • Ideal For: Beginners, warm climates, food production.
    • Temperature: 75–86°F (24–30°C); pH 6.5–9.
    • Pros: Rapid growth, hardy, mild taste, efficient nutrient production.
    • Cons: Require warm water; prolific breeding needs management.
  2. Trout:
    • Ideal For: Cold climates, food production.
    • Temperature: 45–65°F (7–18°C); pH 6.5–8.
    • Pros: High-quality flesh, disease-resistant.
    • Cons: Temperature-sensitive, slower growth, high oxygen demand.
  3. Catfish:
    • Ideal For: Warm climates, food production.
    • Temperature: 65–90°F (18–32°C); pH 7–8.5. Catfish can handle water temperature down to below freezing, although 65–90°F is the recommended temperatures.
    • Pros: High yield, adaptable, tolerant of water fluctuations.
    • Cons: Require high-protein feed; sensitive to handling.
  4. Koi and Goldfish:
    • Ideal For: Ornamental systems, non-food purposes.
    • Temperature: Koi: 59–77°F (15–25°C); Goldfish: 78–82°F (25–28°C).
    • Pros: Hardy, attractive, tolerate temperature swings.
    • Cons: Not for consumption; goldfish produce high waste.
  5. Largemouth Bass:
    • Ideal For: Intermediate users, food production.
    • Temperature: 65–80°F (18–27°C); pH 6–8.
    • Pros: Top feeders, adaptable diet, tasty.
    • Cons: Require large tanks (100–150 gal); sensitive to water conditions.
  6. Salmon:
    • Ideal For: Cold climates, commercial systems.
    • Temperature: 55–65°F (13–18°C); pH 7–8.
    • Pros: Social, cold-tolerant, desirable market value.
    • Cons: Prone to disease, require large tanks and more feed.
  7. Fish for Small-Scale/Desktop Systems:
    • Bettas, Guppies, White Cloud Minnows, Zebra Danios:
      • Pros: Small, hardy, low waste output, suitable for tanks under 5 gallons.
      • Cons: May require heaters (bettas); guppies breed rapidly.

Fish to Avoid:

  • Goldfish (in small systems): High waste output can overwhelm filtration.
  • Large Cichlids, Plecos, Angelfish: Require large spaces; sensitive to water changes; may disturb plants.
  • Salmon and Trout (in small systems): Need precise cold-water conditions and large volumes.

Additional Considerations:

  • Edible vs. Ornamental: Choose based on goals (e.g., tilapia for food, koi for ornamentation).
  • Local Species: Native fish (e.g., bluegill, perch and channel cat) often adapt better and reduce legal issues.
  • System Balance: Match fish with plants having similar temperature/pH needs (e.g., leafy greens with tilapia).

Summary of Recommendations:

  • Beginners/Warm Climates: Tilapia or catfish.
  • Cold Climates: Trout or salmon.
  • Ornamental Systems: Koi or goldfish.
  • Desktop Systems: Bettas or guppies.
  • Commercial Systems: Tilapia or leafy greens (e.g., lettuce, basil).

For further details, you can explore the sources cited, such as for species profiles or for small-system tips. Always assess your specific context-climate, system scale, and goals-to make the optimal choice.

Back to News