Worst Plants for Aquaponics Explained

by Roger Loper

What are the worst plants for aquaponics?

Aquaponics is an innovative and sustainable farming method that combines aquaculture (raising fish) and hydroponics (growing plants without soil). However, not all plants are well-suited for this system due to specific growth requirements, compatibility with fish, and maintenance challenges. Based on our research, here are some of the worst plants for aquaponics and the reasons why they should be avoided:

🌱 1. Chrysanthemums (Chrysanthemum spp.)

  • Why Avoid: Chrysanthemums require slightly alkaline conditions, which can conflict with the neutral pH preferred by most fish and beneficial bacteria in aquaponics systems. They also need specific trace nutrients (e.g., calcium, sulfur, magnesium) that may be deficient in aquaponic water, leading to poor bloom production.

🫐 2. Blueberries (Vaccinium spp.)

  • Why Avoid: Blueberries thrive in highly acidic conditions (pH below 6), which can be harmful to fish and disrupt the nitrogen cycle. They are also competitive, requiring ample space and prone to fungal infections. Their shallow root systems make them difficult to propagate in aquaponics.

🍇 3. Grapes (Vitis spp.)

  • Why Avoid: Grapes require extensive space (up to 50 feet for vines) and structural support, making them impractical for most aquaponics setups. They take years to mature and produce fruit, and their nutrient demands are high, often diverting resources from other plants.

🌿 4. Mint (Mentha spp.)

  • Why Avoid: Mint grows aggressively and can quickly overtake an aquaponics system, choking out other plants. Its roots spread rapidly, requiring frequent pruning and maintenance. While useful, it is best grown in isolation to avoid overcrowding.

🥔 5. Potatoes (Solanum tuberosum)

  • Why Avoid: Potatoes need cool conditions and slightly acidic water (pH 5.5–6.5), which may not be suitable for fish. They also require complex media beds for tuber development, and their above-ground growth does not guarantee tuber production, leading to inefficient resource use.

🧅 6. Onions (Allium cepa)

  • Why Avoid: Onions are sensitive to nitrate concentrations and require specific temperature ranges 53-77°F (12–25°C) for optimal growth. Nutrient imbalances can affect bulb development, and their growth progress is hard to monitor until harvest.

🧡 7. Ginger (Zingiber officinale)

  • Why Avoid: Ginger has a long growth cycle (10+ months) and requires well-drained media beds to prevent root rot. Its sprawling leaves can shade other plants, and it needs additional nutrients beyond what fish waste provides.

🌶️ 8. Peppers (Capsicum spp.)

  • Why Avoid: Peppers require consistently warm and humid conditions, which may not align with the needs of fish. They are also prone to nutrient deficiencies and pests, requiring careful monitoring. However, with proper nutrition, peppers of all kinds will grow well in aquaponics. Many successfully grow pepper in aquaponics, you just need to dial in the correct conditions.

🌺 9. Azaleas (Rhododendron spp.)

  • Why Avoid: Similar to blueberries, azaleas require highly acidic soil, making them incompatible with the neutral pH needed for fish and bacteria in aquaponics systems.

☠️ 10. Toxic Plants (e.g., Eucalypts, Lilypillies)

  • Why Avoid: Plants like eucalypts and lilypillies release toxins (e.g., saponins, rotenone) that can stun or kill fish if their leaves or flowers fall into the water. These should be kept away from aquaponics systems entirely.
    • Tomato leaves are also toxic to fish if they eat the leaves in high quantity.

💎 Summary of Key Issues:

  • pH Conflicts: Plants like blueberries and azaleas require acidic conditions, while most fish thrive in neutral pH.
  • Space and Structural Needs: Vines like grapes and aggressive growers like mint can overcrowd the system.
  • Nutrient Imbalances: Some plants (e.g., chrysanthemums, onions) need specific nutrients that may be lacking in aquaponic water. This can be overcome by proper nutrient/mineral management.
  • Long Growth Cycles: Crops like ginger and grapes take months or years to harvest, reducing efficiency.
  • Toxicity Risks: Plants with toxins can harm fish if introduced accidentally.

💡 Recommendations:

  • Stick to Compatible Plants: Leafy greens (e.g., lettuce, kale), herbs (e.g., basil, parsley), and fast-growing vegetables (e.g., cucumbers) are better suited for aquaponics.
  • Monitor Water Quality: Regularly test pH, nutrient levels, and temperature to ensure compatibility between fish and plants.
  • Avoid Toxic Plants: Ensure no toxic plants are growing near the system to prevent accidental contamination.

 

Back to News